The debate between virtual learning and face-to-face training is a hot one. Both have some obvious pros and cons with various factors involved, including the effectiveness of the actual training, accessibility, cost, and personal preferences. This article will provide a comprehensive comparison of both modalities so that you can decide which is most appropriate for your specific context.
Effectiveness of online learning vs face-to-face training
Online Learning
“The Global Corporate E-Learning market accounted for $14.23 billion in 2017 and is expected to reach $49.87 billion by 2026, growing at a CAGR of 15% during the forecast period.”
The rise of convenient online training courses has been scoring tracks in the business world for a while now, only becoming accelerated by the pandemic. And we are only too pleased to attend from the comfort of our own homes, hair un-brushed, cozy in our pyjamas, a cup of steaming coffee or tea at hand.
But don’t let the blasé attitude fool you, it actually takes a lot more discipline to complete an online training course successfully. There is less support and there’s also less accountability.
With a vast array of courses available across numerous fields, online training enables learners to acquire new skills or knowledge without the need to attend a physical classroom. While it may require strong self-discipline and motivation, online training’s adaptability makes it a popular choice for a diverse range of learners, from professionals to students.
The benefits of virtual training:
-
- Flexibility: The widespread use of technology has broadened access to e-learning resources, making remote and self-paced learning more accessible. This gives learners access to materials and a personalised timeframe to complete coursework at their own pace.
- Autonomy: Online training can accommodate many different learning styles and schedules, eliminating the need to commute, allowing learners to balance education with other commitments.
- Inclusive: It also caters to a wider audience, including those with physical disabilities or those unable to attend traditional classes due to various constraints.
- Technology Integration: By using multimedia tools like videos, interactive simulations, and online forums, online training can enhance the learning experience by connecting people from across the world or allow novel ways of interacting.
- Geographic Flexibility: Accessible from anywhere with an internet connection, making it ideal for remote or international learners, as well as sourcing the best voices in the industry to supply delivery.
- Cost & Resources: Of course, the most obvious benefit to virtual training is that online courses are scalable. There’s no transportation, accommodation, hospitality, or venue costs to consider.
Virtual training is best for working professionals, mature students, remote workers, and busy individuals who need flexible learning options. It can also work really well for remote corporate teams, lifelong learners, international attendees, and those looking to switch careers, offering accessible and self-paced opportunities to acquire new skills and knowledge across various fields.
Online training is best suited to individuals who demonstrate:
-
- Autonomy: Learners who prefer working independently and have strong self-motivation.
- Self-Discipline: Online learning requires a high level of self-motivation and time management skills, as learners must take responsibility for their own progress.
- Adaptability: Suitable for those who need to fit learning around other life commitments, such as work or family.
Face-to-Face Training
The case for online learning is a compelling one, however, the benefits come with equal costs. Due to its remote nature, online learning can discourage engagement and increase feelings of isolation due to limited social interaction, misunderstanding, technical issues, and practicality. Additionally, there is often a delay in receiving feedback from instructors, potential distractions from other online activities, and concerns about the accreditation and quality of some online courses.
In-person training offers a traditional, face-to-face learning experience that fosters direct interaction between instructors and participants. This format allows for immediate feedback, hands-on practice, and collaborative learning, making it especially effective for subjects that require practical skills or teamwork.
The benefits of face to face training:
-
- Direct Interaction: Provides immediate feedback and allows for real-time discussions and clarification of doubts.
- Live Feedback: It’s much easier to provide live feedback to individuals in person. In addition, the training provider can be much more flexible in the way that they deliver.
- Engagement: Can be more engaging due to the physical presence of the instructor and peers, fostering a more dynamic learning environment.
- Collaborative Learning: In-person training encourages teamwork and group activities, fostering collaboration and the sharing of ideas among participants.
- Hands-On Learning: Particularly beneficial for practical skills and hands-on training that require direct supervision and practice.
- Local Networks: Provides opportunities for local networking and building relationships with peers and instructors.
- Structured Environment: The organised setting of in-person training helps maintain a clear schedule and learning path, which can be beneficial for learners who thrive in more structured environments.
In person events are best for circumstances that require:
-
- Structured Environment: Benefits learners who thrive in a structured environment with set schedules and direct supervision.
- Social Interaction: Preferred by individuals who value social interaction and collaborative learning experiences.
Summary
Life is very much about striking balance, and for this reason, we always suggest taking a context specific approach to deciding what type of training is appropriate for your needs.
This may be unclear to you, which is why we’ve set up our own training needs analysis to help you along the path.
Ask yourself:
-
- Is my cohort local or largely remote?
- Even if my cohort is remote, are there vital networking and engagement opportunities to be had in bringing them together & have they met face-to-face before?
- What is the age range of my cohort? (Younger, early careers, individuals can benefit much more from in-person training events)
- Are the demands of my cohorts day-to-day activities too much for them to be able to commit to a physical event?
- Do members of my cohort have any specific limitations or disabilities that would make coming to a physical event extremely taxing or otherwise impossible?
Still unsure: need expert advice? Contact us to schedule a comprehensive training needs analysis.
Both online learning and face-to-face training have their own sets of advantages and disadvantages. The choice between the two often depends on individual needs, learning styles, and specific circumstances. For some, the flexibility and accessibility of online learning are paramount, while others may prioritise the direct interaction and hands-on experiences that face-to-face training offers.
In many cases, a blended approach that combines elements of both can provide a comprehensive and effective learning experience.
